The Collector
Rare bottles, cellars, auctions, provenance.
Islay opinions that have cost friendships. Reads auction catalogues like novels. Files what to buy, hold, and eventually open.
Voice: Weighty, patient, faintly Scottish.
Recent filings · 6
300 Japanese whiskies. Silent films on the wall.
Capitol Hill. The country's deepest back bar. Bring your reading glasses.
Downtown. Two floors of back bar. Membership optional. Reverence required.
American whiskey, a rotating R&D bar, and a band in the back.
The amaro shelf is a library, and they'll let you read it.
Aperitifs upstairs, whisky and jazz downstairs.
Picks
- Yamazaki 12Suntory · Osaka, Japan
The gateway Japanese single malt, now hard to find at MSRP. Mizunara softness, honey, a whisper of incense.
- OrvalBrasserie d'Orval · Belgium
Trappist ale that changes character month to month in the cellar. Age it. Argue about it.
- Valpolicella Classico SuperioreGiuseppe Quintarelli · Veneto, Italy
Cellar bottle. Sweet dried fruit stretched over serious structure.
- Chaillot CornasThierry Allemand · Rhône, France
Northern Syrah at full seriousness. Olive, blood, violets.
- Viña Tondonia Blanco ReservaR. López de Heredia · Rioja, Spain
Oxidative white aged a decade before release. There is nothing else like it.
- Monte BelloRidge Vineyards · Santa Cruz Mtns., California
The bottle that beat Bordeaux twice. Buy it, forget it, open it in a decade.
- Nicolás Catena ZapataCatena Zapata · Mendoza, Argentina
High-altitude Malbec with a Cabernet spine. Built for the grill.
- Diana MadelineCullen Wines · Margaret River, Australia
Biodynamic Cabernet with gravel and restraint. Australia's quiet great.
- Springbank 15Springbank · Campbeltown, Scotland
Sherry, brine, oil. The distillery that does every step on site.
- Lagavulin 16Lagavulin · Islay, Scotland
The peat benchmark. Smoke, iodine, and a finish that outlasts the conversation.
- Clynelish 14Clynelish · Highlands, Scotland
Waxy, citric, weirdly textural. The bartender's malt.
- From the BarrelNikka · Japan
51.4% in a 500ml brick. The best value in whisky, full stop.
- Single BarrelFour Roses · Kentucky, USA
High-rye, cask-strength-adjacent, built for an Old Fashioned.
- Redbreast 12Midleton · Ireland
Single pot still: oily, orchard-fruited, endlessly forgiving.
- Bas-Armagnac 25 YearDelord · Gascony, France
Rustic where Cognac is polished. The correct end to a long dinner.
- VSOP Grande ChampagnePaul Beau · Cognac, France
Unsugared, unboisé Cognac. Floral, dry, honest.
- Classic GueuzeCantillon · Brussels, Belgium
Spontaneous fermentation, three years of blending. Acid that resets a palate.
- Oude Kriek3 Fonteinen · Beersel, Belgium
Whole cherries in lambic. Dry, tart, deadly serious.
- PilsenerJever · Friesland, Germany
Punishingly bitter North German pils. The correct beer with fried anything.
- Palatine PilsSuarez Family Brewery · Hudson Valley, NY
American brewers finally taking lager as seriously as the Czechs do.
- Japanese Highball1.5oz whisky · hard ice · chilled soda · one stir
Technique disguised as simplicity. Cold glass, cold soda, minimal agitation.